Is there lead in lipstick?
What is lead?
Lead is a naturally occurring element in the Earth’s crust. It is usually found combined with other elements in mineral ores. It is not in ‘lead pencils’!
Lead and its compounds are known to cause adverse health effects in humans. Young children are more vulnerable to the effects of lead. Humans are mostly exposed to lead occurs through ingestion or inhalation (eating it or breathing it in).
What's the myth?
‘Lead in lipstick’ is one of those recurring myths that causes unnecessary alarm every time it is aired.
Lead is known to be dangerous to health, so the implication is clear— these products will cause you harm.
The American Council on Science and Health rated ‘lead in lipstick’ as the ‘Number 1 Unfounded Health Scare’ in 2007. That was the year the Campaign for Safe Cosmetics published ‘A Poison Kiss’, a report showing that some lipsticks contained trace levels of lead. ‘Pucker Up for a Dose of Lead’ was the Environmental Working Group’s catchy line in 2017. It’s certainly a topic that lends itself to puns and provoking headlines.
So, is there lead in lipstick, and if so, should you be worried?
No, there is no foundation to this myth.
The ‘Number 1 Unfounded Health Scare’ in 2007.1
What are the facts?
-
Lead is not intentionally added to lipstick
Lead and lead-containing ingredients are not intentionally used in lipsticks.
However, trace levels of lead may be present in lipstick as impurities in other ingredients. Lead is naturally occurring in soil, water and air, so mineral-based (‘natural’) ingredients in particular may contain trace levels.2
This is the case not only for lipstick, but also for other products. Impurities such as these are termed ‘incidental’ ingredients.
-
Very low lead levels in lipsticks do not pose a health risk
At high levels, lead has known toxic effects that can cause a range of health problems. Lead also accumulates in the body and is stored primarily in bones.
But you don’t need to worry about the low lead levels found in lipsticks—they do not pose a health risk.
‘Basically, you will consume more lead from drinking water, or breathing, than you will from applying lipstick.
And since it’s far more dangerous to your health to stop breathing air or drinking water, you can rest assured that your lippy is not going to kill you.’2The US Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has monitored the issue of trace lead in lipstick since the 1990s. Their most recent study of lead levels in 400 lipsticks, published in 2011, found lead at levels ranging from 0.026 to 7.19 ppm (parts per million) with an average of 1.11 ppm. According to the Personal Care Products Council, ‘Using lipstick containing lead at this level would result in exposure 1000 times less than from daily consumption of water meeting EPA drinking water standards.’3
A 2021 study4 on lead in lip products in China found that the concentrations of lead ranged from 0 to 0.52 ppm. The authors stated that this was ‘far lower than the limit set by various countries’ and did not pose a cancer risk. The authors also found that the lead content in lip cosmetics had ‘no obvious influence on blood [lead] concentration of children’.
As an aside, as analytical techniques get more and more sophisticated, it will be possible to detect all kinds of substances at lower and lower concentrations. So, you might hear more claims of ‘[Scary chemical] found in…’ It still doesn’t mean you need to worry—amounts matter! See Extra! Extra! Toxic chemicals found in... for more information.
-
Only a very small proportion of applied lipstick is absorbed or ingested
If you are a lipstick user, how much lipstick do you reckon you would swallow in your lifetime?
There are various estimates out there. For example, according to snopes.com, the Melbourne Sunday Herald Sun reported that ‘the average woman swallows about 4.5 kg in a lifetime’.5
Let’s put this figure to the test. Assume a committed lipstick wearer uses lipstick from the ages of 15 to 75. If the average weight of lipstick in a tube is 3 grams, they would have to use, and swallow…
…every single bit of 25 lipsticks each year!
And this is without factoring in the lipstick that smears off during the day, for example on drinking utensils, or other people… That’s about half a lipstick a week.Are you buying a new lipstick every couple of weeks? Does this sound realistic to you?
The bottom line?
The trace levels of lead in lipstick pose no threat to human health. You can continue to use lipsticks with confidence. (All 25 tubes yearly…!)
No need to…
stop using lipstick or even pay attention to this myth, next time it raises its head.
But please do...
try not to eat your lipstick :)
Sources
- American Council on Science and Health 2007, Top Ten Unfounded Health Scares of 2007 #1: Lipstick is toxic (lead in cosmetics)
- Australian Academy of Science - Mythbusting the presence of cosmetic nasties: Lead in lipstick
- Andrew McDougall, 23 February 2012, Cosmetics Design USA, ‘PCPC defends FDA study of lead found in lipsticks'
- Li, Y. et al. 2021, ‘Trace Metal Lead Exposure in Typical Lip Cosmetics From Electronic Commercial Platform: Investigation, Health Risk Assessment and Blood Lead Level Analysis’, Frontiers in Public Health vol 9.
- Snopes.com, Does the Average Woman Swallow 6 Pounds of Lipstick During Her Lifetime?